Page 182 - SUMMARIES OF GIOVANNI BOCCACCIO’S DECAMEON : A Visionary Journey In 100 Stories And 100 Etchings By Petru Russu
P. 182
The Judge from the Marches
The Fifth Novell of Day Eight shifts its gaze from gullible painters and
scheming widows to the inflated ego of a judge, and punctures it with
pointed laughter. What unfolds is not a tale of romance or seduction,
but of intellectual mischief, as three bright young men orchestrate an
elaborate farce to expose incompetence disguised as authority.
At the center of the tale is a judge sent from the Marches to Florence, a
man endowed with power but pitifully lacking in judgment. His inflated
sense of self and shallow reasoning make him a ripe target, especially in
a city that prizes wit above pomposity. Enter the three pranksters, who
fabricate a fantastical dispute over a stolen ring. The details they provide
are deliberately contradictory and absurd, drawing the judge into a tangle
of confusion that he is utterly unequipped to sort out.
Rather than apply logic or composure, the judge flounders, flusters, and finally
throws up his hands in defeat, dismissing the case altogether. His reaction
doesn’t just expose his incompetence, it does so with flair. What might have
remained whispered rumor becomes public spectacle, and the people laugh
not just at him, but at the broken machinery of power he represents.
What gives the tale its bite is not cruelty, but clarity. Boccaccio isn’t just
poking fun, he’s pulling back the curtain on systems that allow authority
without merit. And the pranksters? They don’t need fists or protests to
challenge injustice. All they need is a little fiction and a lot of timing.
DYNAMIC GEOMETRIC INTERPLAY This tale sits neatly in Day Eight’s arc: the power of cleverness over
HIGHLIGHTS THE SATIRE
position, trickery over tyranny. Would you like a comparison between the
AND HYPOCRISY, VISUALLY
judge’s downfall and Calandrino’s humiliation, two kinds of foolishness
EMPHASIZING THE SHIFT FROM
AUTHORITY TO RIDICULE. with two very different flavors? I’ve got just the angle.
DECAMERON 180 181
